15 Years on Flatbush Avenue
A licensed, family-run gold buyer at the heart of Little Caribbean, Flatbush — built on transparency, not pressure.
Licensed & Accountable
Gold City Jewelry operates under NYC Second-Hand Dealer License #2116168-DCWP. We test every item in front of the customer, price against the live market, and keep our payout structure — 80%–100% of market value — the same for everyone who walks through the door.
The Neighborhood
We’re located at 859 Flatbush Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11226, in the heart of Little Caribbean. For 15 years, Brooklyn families have brought us their gold and heirlooms — and for 15 years we’ve paid them fairly for it.
“Googling for Gold: Research finds New York searches for gold - a lot”
News 12 · Katelynn Ulrich · July 19, 2024
I've been buying gold on Flatbush Avenue for 15 years, and I still test every piece myself, right at the counter, in front of the customer.
This neighborhood has trusted me with heirlooms, old jewelry, and family pieces they weren't sure what to do with — and I don't take that lightly. You'll always get a fair, transparent offer based on that day's market price, nothing hidden.
Stop by any time — no appointment needed.
— Syed Hakim, Owner
4.9 Stars, 101 Reviews
My experience here was great. They took the time to explain details of different types of gold and the actual value of each pieces. When it comes to selling, the process was fast, easy, and seamless. If you are looking to sell your jewelry, I recommend Gold City Jewelry.
— Tracey G.
Ready to Find Out What It’s Worth?
Walk in any time during business hours, or request a free quote online first — no obligation, no pressure.
859 Flatbush Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11226